The Best Mascaras in Australia

The Best Mascaras in Australia: How to Find Your Perfect Match

Mascara has earned its place as one of the most-loved products in any makeup bag. Whether you wear a full face of makeup or simply want to brighten and define your eyes, a good mascara can make lashes appear longer, fuller and more lifted in seconds.

With so many formulas available, choosing the best mascara in Australia can feel confusing. Some mascaras promise volume, others focus on length, curl, definition or all-day wear. The right choice depends on your natural lashes, your preferred makeup look and how you want the formula to perform throughout the day.

The best mascara is not necessarily the most dramatic or expensive option. It is the one that suits your lashes, feels comfortable and gives you the finish you actually want.

What Makes a Great Mascara?

A quality mascara should do more than simply add colour to your lashes. It should separate, define and enhance them without feeling heavy or uncomfortable.

When comparing formulas, consider how well the mascara performs across the following areas:

Length
Volume
Curl and lift
Definition
Smudge resistance
Water resistance
Ease of removal
Suitability for sensitive eyes

The mascara brush also plays an important role. A narrow, precise brush may help reach shorter lashes and create separation, while a fuller brush can deposit more product and build volume more quickly.

If you are comparing formulas for different lash needs, browse our collection of cruelty-free mascaras to explore options for length, volume and everyday definition.

Different Types of Mascara

Not every mascara is designed to create the same result. Understanding the main types can make choosing the right formula much easier.

Lengthening Mascara

Lengthening mascaras are designed to coat and define the full length of each lash. Some formulas include fibres that build onto the tips of the lashes, creating the appearance of extra length.

They are particularly useful for short, fine or lightly coloured lashes that need more visible definition.

Volumising Mascara

Volumising mascaras create the appearance of thicker and fuller lashes. They usually have buildable formulas that deposit more product around each lash.

A volumising formula can be a good choice for evening makeup or anyone who wants a more noticeable lash look.

Curling and Lifting Mascara

Curling mascaras are designed to help lashes appear more lifted and open. These formulas work particularly well when used after an eyelash curler.

A curved brush may also help support the lash shape while the mascara is applied.

Waterproof and Water-Resistant Mascara

Waterproof mascara is designed for stronger resistance to water, while water-resistant mascara is generally intended to withstand light moisture, humidity and everyday wear.

For many people, a water-resistant formula offers enough durability without being as difficult to remove as a fully waterproof mascara.

Clear Mascara

Clear mascara provides grooming and separation without adding dark colour. It can be used for a minimal makeup look or brushed through the brows for subtle hold and definition.

How to Choose the Right Mascara

The best mascara for you depends on your natural lashes and the result you want to achieve.

If You Want More Length

Choose a lengthening formula with a brush that helps separate individual lashes. A lightweight, buildable texture will usually create cleaner definition than a very thick formula.

If You Want More Volume

Look for a volumising mascara that can be layered without becoming overly dry or clumpy. A fuller brush may help build thickness more quickly.

If You Have Straight Lashes

A lifting or curling mascara may help lashes hold a more elevated shape. Curling your lashes before application can also make a noticeable difference.

If You Prefer Natural Makeup

A lightweight formula, brown mascara or clear mascara may be a better fit than a bold volumising product. These options can define the eyes without making lashes appear overly dramatic.

If You Have Sensitive Eyes

Check the individual product information carefully and look for formulas designed with eye comfort in mind. Proper removal is also important, as rubbing or pulling at the lashes may cause irritation.

You can also explore our wider eye makeup collection to find products that work alongside mascara, including eyeliner, eyeshadow and brow makeup.

How to Apply Mascara

Even a high-quality mascara can clump or smudge if too much is applied at once. A few simple techniques can help create a cleaner result.

Begin with clean, dry lashes.
Curl your lashes before applying mascara.
Remove excess product from the wand using the opening of the tube.
Place the brush at the base of the upper lashes.
Gently wiggle the wand from side to side.
Sweep the brush upwards towards the tips.
Apply a second coat while the first coat is still slightly wet.
Use the tip of the wand carefully on shorter inner and outer lashes.

For a softer finish, concentrate the product at the base of the lashes and use less on the tips. For more drama, build thin layers rather than applying one heavy coat.

Common Mascara Mistakes

Many mascara problems are caused by application habits rather than the formula itself.

Pumping the Wand

Pumping the mascara wand repeatedly can push air into the tube and cause the product to dry out more quickly. Instead, gently twist the wand inside the tube before removing it.

Applying Too Many Dry Coats

Adding more mascara after the previous layer has completely dried can cause lashes to become stiff and clumpy. Apply additional coats while the formula is still slightly wet.

Curling Lashes After Mascara

Lashes should be curled before mascara is applied. Using an eyelash curler after the product has dried can cause the lashes to stick to the curler and may increase the risk of breakage.

Using Mascara for Too Long

Mascara should be replaced regularly, particularly if the texture, smell or performance changes. It should also be discarded after an eye infection.

Removing Mascara Too Aggressively

Rubbing the eyes can pull at the lashes and irritate the delicate skin around them. Hold an appropriate makeup remover over the closed eye for several seconds before gently wiping the product away.

Building a Complete Eye Makeup Routine

Mascara is often the final step in an eye makeup routine, but it can be combined with other products to create very different looks.

For a simple daytime look, you may only need mascara, softly groomed brows and a neutral eyeshadow. For greater definition, add eyeliner along the lash line or deepen the outer corner with a darker eyeshadow.

Brown eyeliner and mascara can create a softer finish, while black mascara and a defined liner usually produce a stronger result.

Explore our range of cruelty-free eye makeup to build a routine that suits your style, from understated everyday definition to a more polished evening look.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best mascara in Australia?

The best mascara depends on your lashes and your preferred finish. Some people prioritise length, while others want volume, curl, water resistance or a more natural look.

Is waterproof mascara better?

Not necessarily. Waterproof mascara offers stronger resistance to water but can be more difficult to remove. A water-resistant formula may be more practical for everyday wear.

How many coats of mascara should I apply?

One coat is usually enough for natural definition. Two coats can add more length and volume. Additional coats should be applied before the previous layer has fully dried.

Should I use brown or black mascara?

Black mascara creates stronger definition, while brown mascara offers a softer finish. Brown can work particularly well for daytime makeup, fair lashes or anyone who prefers a subtle look.

Can people with sensitive eyes wear mascara?

Many mascaras are designed with sensitive eyes in mind. Always check the individual product details and remove the mascara carefully at the end of the day.

Finding Your Perfect Mascara

The best mascara is the one that complements your lashes and fits naturally into your routine. Start by deciding whether you want more length, volume, curl, definition or a softer everyday finish.

You may also find that more than one formula is useful. A natural mascara may suit everyday wear, while a volumising or water-resistant option may be better for events, warm weather or longer days.

Browse our full mascara collection to compare cruelty-free formulas, or explore our eye makeup products to complete your look.

Previous Article Next Article